Was Graeme Shinnie's red card appeal 'frivolous' and who will make the Premiership top six? Saturday Jury

Michael Gannon: The tackle was unnecessary and probably a red these days. The extra game ban looks harsh but Aberdeen must have known they were on to plumbs with the appeal.

Andrew Newport: It’s a stick on red card under the laws of the game these days so for me, he was bang to rights. The extra game ban seems harsh, however. As ever common sense in short supply at Hampden.

Fraser Wilson: The red card was harsh so I completely understand the Dons’ appeal - particularly when there are similar cases which have been won. For the SFA to deem it frivolous and add an extra game on is a shocker.

Michael Gannon: There’s a fag paper between them. Ange Postecoglou’s side are up against a stronger Rangers but for 18 months the Rodgers crew were sensational.

Andrew Newport: Not yet. Rodgers’ squad was well on its way to a triple Treble by the time the Northern Irishman scurried off back to the Premier League. But if Ange’s side keep up their remarkable winning run they can make a strong claim for the tag.

Fraser Wilson: Equally swashbuckling and equally impressive. Ange Postecoglou has gelled a formidable team together but if you take talents like Kyogo, Jota, Reo Hatate and Cameron Carter-Vickers on their individual merits then I think there’s more star quality to this side.

Michael Gannon: The man in charge has every right to call the shots but the entire situation at Tynecastle is a strange self-inflicted mess.

Andrew Newport: Time will tell. No doubt if the Jambos fail to claim third this will be a stick used to beat Naisy but there’s no denying Snodgrass had dropped off from the lofty standards he was setting in his early days at Tynecastle.

Fraser Wilson: To dump the most experienced member of the squad on day one in