Manchester United player ratings as Tyrell Malacia and Bruno Fernandes poor vs Man City

David de Gea

Made the odd save and could do little about any of the goals as he was badly let down by United's poor defensive organisation. 3

Diogo Dalot

Booked in the second minute and never really recovered against the tricky Jack Grealish and City punished United from crosses. 2

Raphael Varane

The dam burst after Varane succumbed to an October injury. Off the pitch when Erling Haaland made it 2-0, the Norwegian eluded him to make it 3-0. Came off injured. 3

Read more: United reaction to City loss

Lisandro Martinez

City dominated United from crosses but Martinez was not obviously culpable and more a victim of the naive approach of his manager. 4

Tyrell Malacia

Was alarmingly distant from Phil Foden off the ball and never got close to him on it. A chastening derby debut where he did little right. Substituted at the pause. 1

Scott McTominay

Blocked heroically to briefly keep the game at 0-0 but was easy pickings for the best midfield in the league. A reminder he is a stop-gap, not a specialist, in defensive midfield. 3

Christian Eriksen

Failed to track Foden for the opening goal and was inexplicably tasked with handling the monstrous Haaland at the game-killing corner. Poorest performance since Brentford. 3

Antony

A luxury in the first-half but rallied and scored brilliantly to make it 4-1 with more than half-an-hour to play. Then City responded. 5

Bruno Fernandes

Ineffective with and without the ball. City were not remotely startled by any of United's pressing and Fernandes regressed against the world-class Kevin de Bruyne. 2

Jadon Sancho

Carelessly lost the ball and United were soon losing. Did little to protect Malacia and did not do much more to test Kyle Walker or Joao Cancelo. 2

Marcus Rashford

Even against