Manchester City arrived for this fixture through streets already decked out for Halloween, and left Liverpool still haunted by the spectre of Anfield.
Mo Salah scored the only goal of the game to inflict the first defeat of the season on a defensive Blues outfit and prove Pep Guardiola right that Liverpool are still very much contenders to win the Premier League title.
Defeat at Anfield may be nothing new but, given the form of the respective sides going into it, and the presence of the goalscoring phenomenon that is Erling Haaland wearing City colours, it felt like an opportunity missed to inflict serious damage on a Liverpool side already hurting.
City of course won here powerfully in 2020 when Phil Foden tore the home team apart, but with that game taking place behind closed doors due to Covid restrictions, the wait for the visiting fans to see a win at this ground is now set to stretch into a 21st season.