Livingston's winless run stretched to 11 games as they were held to a scoreless draw at home to St Johnstone in a game that won't live long in the memory.
The first half was a drab affair with neither side having the courage to get the ball down and look to control possession. The Lions did at least pepper the Saints area with set-plays but they never looked like taking advantage.
Jason Holt's stinging effort that was tipped wide by Dimitar Mitov from 30 yards out was the closest either team came to opening the scoring before the break.
The hosts showed attacking intent in the early stages of the second half with James Penrice seeing an effort blocked while skipper Mick Devlin tried his luck from distance as space opened up in front of him - but curled a tame effort into the arms of Mitov.