'The only conclusion' - Ratcliffe has already explained why Thomas Tuchel was unlikely Man United manager

Of all the candidates to replace Erik ten Hag as Manchester United manager, Thomas Tuchel was the one who could present the most glittering CV and the most compelling personality to manage a club the size of this one.

The 50-year-old German is a master communicator in his native language and in English and in two press conferences ahead of United’s Champions League group stage games against Bayern Munich last season he spoke superbly, including giving his opinion of the similarity of the challenge in managing both clubs.

But there is a reason his candidacy to add another ‘super club’ to his resume never really got off the ground. In fact, there are probably several.

ALSO READ: Ten Hag's former United coach gives verdict on future after summer exit

ALSO READ: United stall on Sofyan Amrabat decision as Ten Hag wait goes on

Tuchel’s Champions League success with Chelsea in 2020/21 was a major achievement, but aside from that his honours don’t stand out. A couple of routine league titles with Paris St-Germain, the 2022/23 Bundesliga title with Bayern Munich that owed more to Borussia Dortmund’s final-day collapse than Bayern’s brilliance.

This season he has guided Bayern to third in the Bundesliga, ending their run of 11 straight titles despite signing Harry Kane (36 goals in 32 Bundesliga games) last summer. The brilliance of Bayer Leverkusen has dominated the narrative in Germany, but Tuchel has steered Bayern to what in their world must go down as a dismal campaign.

Then there is his record of falling out with the executives at almost every club he has worked at. He is a notoriously demanding and prickly character and his war of words with Bayern Munich’s honourary president Uli Hoeness was merely the latest example.