The growing concern about quarterback J.J. McCarthy’s struggles has reached a fever pitch with the second-year pro failing to spark an offense that was expected to push the Minnesota Vikings into title contention. Although the team’s woes amid a 4-7 start are not solely attributable to their young quarterback, McCarthy’s subpar play has contributed to a disappointing campaign that has raised questions about his long-term potential as the team's QB1.
With his 2024 quarterback classmates – particularly Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye and Bo Nix – inching towards elite QB1 status, the skeptics are ready to dismiss the Vikings’ QB1 after a bumpy six-game start to his NFL career.
While I understand McCarthy’s numbers have not been impressive – his 54.1 percent completion rate, 57.9 passer rating, and 5.8 yards per pass attempt average ranking among the league’s worst – it is too soon to give up on a young, talented quarterback who needs more game experience to acclimate to the league fully.
Remember, McCarthy entered the NFL with just 28 collegiate starts under his belt after leading Michigan to a 27-1 mark that included a national title and a pair of Big 10 championships. After missing his entire rookie season due to a knee injury and five games of the 2025 campaign with a high ankle sprain, the second-year pro is undergoing the growing pains most quarterbacks experience when they step into the league.
From the playbook struggles to dealing with the complexities of coverage and the speed of the NFL defenders, young quarterbacks can be overwhelmed by the pro game. Additionally, it takes time for play-callers to fully understand a young quarterback's strengths and weaknesses and which concepts work best for his
Read more on foxnews.com
foxnews.com
