Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen? Chiefs or Bills? Debating Championship Sunday

Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen have history.

In Sunday's AFC Championship Game, the superstar quarterbacks will square off for the ninth time — and it'll be a tiebreaker of sorts, with each player sitting at four wins. But, of course, not all wins are measured equally. Mahomes is 3-0 in the postseason against Buffalo, and that's what makes this such a crucial matchup for Allen's legacy. Their rivalry ultimately won't be viewed as much of a rivalry if one QB never wins the meaningful games.

The showdown assures that one of them will be in the Super Bowl and serves as the nightcap for what should be a captivating Championship Sunday. In the NFC, one team has arguably the best roster in football, while the other boasts the best rookie QB in NFL history. 

In preparation for Bills-Chiefs and Commanders-Eagles, FOX Sports NFL writers Ben Arthur and Henry McKennaengaged in a spirited conversation centered on Sunday's four starting quarterbacks and how the title games might unfold. 

Josh Allen has been statistically superior to Patrick Mahomes for two full seasons now. Have you reached the point where you expect Allen to outperform Mahomes, even in the postseason?

Ben Arthur: Not really. Not while Mahomes remains in a different class when it comes to postseason football. Not only is he 3-0 against Allen in the playoffs, but he'll be playing in his seventh straight AFC Championship Game. Mahomes is at his very best when the lights are brightest. Ultimately, that's all that really matters, even if his raw stats in the regular season haven't necessarily been what they were earlier in his tenure as Chiefs QB1. 

Henry McKenna: Yeah, Mahomes is a back-to-back Super Bowl champion because of his unique ability to close games in the