Man City player ratings vs Manchester United as Bernardo Silva class

Ederson: Made important saves when he needed to, including from McTominay at 1-0, to show his defensive improvement. 8

Walker: A few loose passes and rash decisions but still kept Rashford quiet and attacked well. 7

Stones: Showed how much City have missed him with vital tackles and control on the ball. 8

Dias: Strong when he needed to be and also enjoyed himself on the ball. Dealt well enough with Hojlund's pace. 7

Gvardiol: Looked nervous early on and was pressured by Fernandes into giving the ball away twice, but recovered and grew in confidence. 6

Rodri: Earned the first penalty with his run into the box and showed himself again to be the main man pulling the strings. 8

Silva: The best player on the pitch, and probably any pitch with this performance. Another Old Trafford masterclass. 9

Alvarez: Struggled to get and then stay involved in the game but still troubled United with his running and put in some good corners. 7

Foden: A needless yellow card and upset Guardiola with some rash play, but worked hard and got his goal. 7

Grealish: Linked up really well with Silva and fully merited his place ahead of Doku. Clever pass for the second goal. 8

Haaland: Two goals and an assist is not bad at all for a man still finding his form. A few more big chances missed but a terrific performance leading the line. 8

Kovacic (for Alvarez, 86) - too late to mark

Doku (for Grealish, 86) - too late to mark

Not used: Ortega, Ake, Gomez, Lewis, Phillips, Nunes, Bobb