England in West Indies: Joe Root, Ben Stokes & tourists' other players assessed after series defeat

After another series defeat in the West Indies, and a winless run that has extended to nine games, there are more questions around England.

With their next Test not until 2 June, when they play New Zealand at Lord's, BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew and the Mirror's Dean Wilson assess which players are in credit, who has work to do and who has gone backwards during the tour as part of the BBC Test Match Special podcast.

Innings:Six, Runs:184, Average:30.66, High score:121

Agnew: He's got work to do. He made a familiar mistake because he got out hitting a booming drive in the third Test and nicking to second slip. That was disappointing because he'd had a pretty good series.

Innings:Six, Runs:126, Average:21.00, High score:31

Agnew: He's shown a good technique. He'll get one or two more shots in the locker, but Sir Alastair Cook scored a million runs with only three or four shots to go on. He's in credit for me.

Wilson: In the end he was the only batsman who stood firm in Grenada and in the end it was a bit of a shooter that got him. He's got a little bit of credit.

Innings:Six, Runs:289, Average:48.16, High score:153, Wicket:One

Agnew: He scored successive hundreds and I think you need to keep that separate to his captaincy. The good things are that his captaincy woes haven't affected his batting. He's obviously in credit from a batting perspective.

Innings:Six, Runs:197, Average:32.83, High score: 91, Wickets:Two

Agnew: I liked him. He batted with lots of flair, but it is disappointing how he got out in the second innings in Grenada. He'd have credit in the bank for me.

Wilson: He's in credit because the way he played in both Antigua and Barbados was for the team and very selfless. When conditions were in his favour