2025 MLB core rankings: Who has the most star talent? - ESPN

As we head toward the home stretch of the 2025 season, it's time for my annual ranking of the core talent of all 30 MLB teams. This judges teams based on which players they have under contract through the next two full seasons — and you'll find many clubs at the top of this list are in the thick of the playoff races over the final month.

For this exercise, salaries don't matter and age isn't a factor — but I'll round up on projecting young players (and down on older players) because I'm projecting/ranking teams for a two-plus-year period. Very few players in either level of A-Ball are listed because they likely will contribute only at the end of 2027, if at all, even if they're a top prospect.

To make it easier to see which team has more talent, I split players into three tiers: elite (5ish WAR talent, or perennial All-Stars with MVP chances), plus (3-5ish WAR types) and solid (1.5-3ish WAR, or lower-end starters and valuable role players). I included players who have easy-to-hit vesting options or club/player options that are likely to be picked up, but left out players with likely-to-be-exercised opt-outs. There's some subjectivity in this area; star players who don't qualify are called out below.

Players are listed in general order of my preference within each tier, so you can argue for a player who's on the top/bottom of a tier to move up or down or flip two players who are back-to-back in the same tier. And the overall ranking isn't coming from an algorithm that judges the teams or their players in each tier — I'm still comparing each list one by one. It's often hard to compare the next 2½ years of value of a prospect in Double-A versus a proven veteran having a down season.

Jump to a team:

AL East: BAL | BOS | NYY