Our top 100 college football players for the 2023 season list is live and as expected, Caleb Williams came in at No. 1, a position the Heisman Trophy winner held at the end of last season.
But as with any ranking, not everyone is in exact agreement with how the results of our voting turned out. So, which players are ranked too high?
Who should have been in the top 10? Who was snubbed altogether? Our reporters point out what they would have done differently. Jump to: Players who missed top 10 | Ranked too highRanked too low | Unranked players | Newcomers to watch Chris Low: A case could be made that Ole Miss' Quinshon Judkins is the best running back in the country and yet he's ranked fourth on our list, albeit behind three really good players.
Either way, Judkins warrants top-10 status overall. All he did last season was rush for more yards as a freshman (1,567) than anybody in SEC history not named Herschel Walker.