Cyriel Dessers Rangers transfer exit splits the Jury as Celtic urged caution over Evan Ferguson

ANDREW NEWPORT: If the fee is big enough then of course. Rangers have let far too much money slip through their fingers by failing to sell when the price is right. Dessers scores plenty - but misses more. He’s 30 and his value will only decline from here.

SCOTT MCDERMOTT: Only if the price is right. I'd keep Dessers to be second choice striker at Ibrox because of his excellent goal return. But he's 30 years old and is a high earner so if Rangers can make a profit on him with a sale of around £4million they have to consider it.

MICHAEL GANNON: If Rangers can make a profit then it’s worth taking the dosh. Dessers is on top dollar and he has delivered goals. He’s still unreliable in big games, on big money and the wrong side of 30. Take the dosh and invest it.

ANDY: He looked a proper prospect when he burst onto the scene with a hat-trick against Newcastle a couple of years back but he’s only scored three goals since November 2023. Idah isn’t the finish product either but at least he’s been a regular contributor for Celtic.

SCOTT: With both players playing at their best, I think Ferguson is a better striker. He has more natural ability, as well as being a powerhouse up front. But he's toiled for two years now in the Premier League and Rodgers sees real potential and development in Idah.

MICHAEL: The Ferguson of 12 months ago would have been a good option but it’s more uncertain now after a poor season. A loan deal late in the window could be an option but Celtic should be looking at cheaper targets before then.

ANDY: Maxxy is right to put negotiations on hold as breaking our World Cup duck is all that matters. If Clarke can do that job he’ll get the keys to Scotland, never mind a new deal.

SCOTT: If he gets us to the